The films of the original Star Wars Trilogy are iconic, generation-bridging parts of science fiction lore and likely never to be supplanted from their place in history. There have been other epic series' that have come since; the most impressive of which would be Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy. But given the fact that these were merely adaptations of existing works and not original stories it falls even that much more short.
Lucas, for all his later stumbles and faults, had a vision for Star Wars, Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi. He scoped the arc of each character and developed the plot with an emphasis on drawing the audience in and making them genuinely care about Luke, Han, Leia, Chewie, C-3PO and R2D2. This is something that so many other filmmakers have tried to do and failed; he should be applauded for his creativity, vision and foresight.
With the sale to Disney the franchise was put in the hands of the most competent director in Sci-fi films right now. Six years prior JJ Abrams had resurrected the basically dead Star Trek franchise with a new cast. He forged his own path going so far as to put his version in an alternate universe from canon to maintain what had come before without letting it influence his vision.
Disney, perhaps in collaboration with Abrams, did a similar thing in the SWU - all the books, comics, etc. that had been produced since Jedi were expunged from canon. I was among those fans who had hoped without reason that Episodes VII-IX would be the Timothy Zahn story; by far the best series of the Star Wars Expanded Universe (SWEU) but those hopes were dashed. If you haven't read this series, known as the Thrawn Trilogy, I would highly, highly recommend picking it up.
Unlike restarting Star Trek, which had already produced numerous television series and nearly a dozen movies, Star Wars was living on the gasps of what the original trilogy could still command after the debacle that was the prequels. There are certainly SW Fans who will stand by those films as they are zealots and ravenous fans too blind to recognize failure in their messiah. I don't mean to cast aspersions upon all SW Fans who enjoyed episodes I-III, but if you can't see the obvious flaws, storyline errors and insanely contradictory plot points these films created you are not someone whose opinion on film that will hold any weight with me.
So here was the task set before Abrams: resurrect the Star Wars Universe, bring together fans of the original trilogy (meaning: don't ignore that which came before) and draw in a whole new generation while simultaneously set up a franchise which Disney plopped down $5.5 Billion (will a B).
I chose to keep myself rather distant from the rumors and stories out there about the film's plot, characters and story. It felt important to me that I go into this experience with my eyes as unclouded as possible. I watched the trailers, yes. But I ignored all goings on and chatter out there. When I sat down in that theater today I had an open mind and no expectations.
Let's start with what I didn't like: I was definitely disappointed in the lack of screen time for Captain Phasma. It is entirely possible that her character will play a much larger role in the subsequent films but for me her absence was noticeable. The characterization of Luke was not to my liking. A bad thing happens and he runs away? That's not the Luke I knew from the original movies; which is all we're supposed to know. As much as I tried to disassociate what I know from the SWEU the use of lightsabers by non-force trained persons was bothersome to me. It's a hurdle I don't think I'm easy to clear. Who's fighting who and why; there's an established government (the presumably good guys - The Republic), the First Order - who rose from the ashes of the Empire, and the Resistance...which is apparently the guerrilla fighting arm of the Republic? It is not at all explained and we are left wondering why it was set up this way.
What I did like: the character dialogue was brilliant at times. When Poe Dameron and Kylo Ren first meet, Poe's little glib remark, "Do you speak first, or do I speak first?" is spot on and hilarious. Though Poe doesn't have an excessive amount of screen time this line is perfectly in line with who he is as the "new Solo" (calling it now). The relationship between Rey and Finn - two people who have not lived the life they wanted and are drawn together by forces beyond their control make a distinct and pure connection. The story of Han and Leia; its construction helps at a reality to the time that came before and puts a human face on the Universe-spanning story line. The fact that unexpected things happen regularly and without fear of the repercussions; Abrams isn't afraid to anger or disappoint fans - which is the exact opposite of where Lucas had taken the franchise, I have to give him credit for that.
I fully reserve the right to amend this review after seeing the film a second time if I come away with a much happier feeling. But for now I leave you with this: Star Wars is alive and well. And that is something we can all be happy about.
Tb
